We make a lot of assumptions about people when they are born — especially those assumptions based on the physical features we have traditionally used to determine a person’s gender. The time has come to rethink these assumptions. Actually, it’s past time we did away with these assumptions. But we have to start sometime and I’m suggesting that the time is now.
I do understand where our assumptions came from and their usefulness, at one time, in determining what a person might be allowed to do, what jobs were appropriate for someone, who a person could be, what salary might be offered. Those assumptions are no longer (and never were actually) legitimate or even worthy of the ignorance and prejudice that engendered them.
Given time and new information people can learn new things or new ways of looking at things. After all, we went from believing that the sun travels around the Earth to understanding that the Earth travels around the sun. Even though we continue to say “sunrise” and “sunset,” we do understand that it is the Earth’s travels around the sun that make sunrise and sunset appear to happen.
We now have information that allows us to understand that the physical manifestation of our old definition of gender is an assumption and not reality for many people. We know that the appearance of physical genitalia happens at one stage of fetal development and that gender identity happens during an altogether different stage of development. This makes gender identity an inborn developmental trait rather than a post natal decision or a lifestyle choice.
Gender identity then can be but is not necessarily consistent with the outward appearance of genitalia. So, why do we continue to indicate gender on an individual’s birth certificate when we cannot possibly know a person’s gender until that person is old enough to articulate their gender identity? Perhaps it is time to celebrate the birth of a human child indicating date, time, birth weight, parents’ information, and leave gender identity off entirely. Or, perhaps, leave it blank to be completed at a formal family celebration when the child declares who they are.